star

Troubleshooting

Problem: Beans smell strongly of ammonia
Solution: Over-fermented. Next time, check earlier or reduce temperature slightly. The fridge rest will mellow the smell.

Problem: Not enough strings/stickiness
Solution: Fermentation time was too short, temperature too low, or beans were too dry. Stir vigorously—this helps develop strings!

Problem: Strange off-smell or unexpected colors
Solution: Contamination occurred. Discard batch and sterilize everything more thoroughly next time.

What's normal: A soft whitish fuzz on beans, a cheese-like aroma, and that distinctive fermented smell are all perfectly normal!

Tips for Success

  • Use smaller soybeans (natto soybeans) if available—they produce milder, more traditional natto
  • Fresh homemade natto tastes better and smells milder than store-bought due to better temperature control
  • Beginners can use more starter than the recipe calls for—it increases success rates
  • Don't skip the refrigerator rest—it genuinely improves flavor
  • Stirring natto just before eating develops the best texture

Why Make Your Own?

Commercially produced natto usually comes in styrofoam packaging. Plus - whilst they are a little larger - we have great GMO free, organic soy beans here in Australia. And it's easy!! There is one in Sydney that I do love - called  Dai's Natto. 


Get started: Shop The Fermentary Natto Starter—professionally cultured Bacillus subtilis specifically formulated for home natto making. One packet makes multiple batches. Available in our online shop alongside organic soybeans.

There is a more comprehensive story and recipe in my book Ferment for Good.

Written by Sharon Flynn

More stories

Making a Nukadoko Bed

With care, your nukadoko can last for years, even decades. As it ages, it develops deeper, more complex flavours - layers of umami and funk that can't be rushed. In Japan, moving house often involves the careful transport of the family nukadoko bed above all else. You're not just making pickles; you're tending a living legacy.