Why Make Your Own?
Cost: A batch of homemade bokashi bran costs $5-10 and lasts for months, versus $25-40 for commercial products.
Control: You know exactly what's in it—no mystery ingredients, no fillers, no concerns about quality.
Connection: If you're making milk kefir or yogurt, you've already got the perfect inoculant in your whey. Why buy expensive EM (Effective Microorganisms) solutions when you've got beneficial bacteria right in your fridge?
Flexibility: Once you understand the process, you can adapt it—use different grains, adjust moisture levels, scale up or down.
The Fermentation Connection
If you make sauerkraut, kimchi, or milk kefir, you already understand what's happening here. You're creating an environment where beneficial bacteria thrive and harmful ones can't survive:
- Lactobacillus bacteria dominate the fermentation (same as in your kraut)
- The low pH (acidity) they create suppresses pathogens and prevents putrefaction
- Anaerobic conditions (no oxygen) favor the good guys
- The result is preserved, pre-digested organic matter—fermented rather than rotted
The only difference is you're applying these principles to kitchen scraps instead of vegetables.
Troubleshooting Bokashi Bran
It smells rotten during fermentation: Too much moisture or contamination. The mixture should smell sweet-sour, like pickles or yogurt, not putrid. Start again with less liquid.
Nothing seems to be happening: Could be too dry, too cold, or your inoculant wasn't active. Try again with more liquid or in a warmer spot.
Blue or black mold: This is bad mold—contamination. White mold is fine (beneficial yeast), but colorful mold means something went wrong. Discard and start over.
It won't dry out: Too much moisture to begin with. Spread it thinner, use a fan, or put it somewhere warmer with good airflow.
Troubleshooting Bokashi Process
Bucket smells rotten: Not enough bran, or air is getting in. Use more bran per layer and check your lid seal.
Black or fuzzy mold in bucket: Normal! Small amounts of white mold are beneficial yeast. Black fuzzy mold means contamination—usually too much air or not enough bran.
Fruit flies: Lid isn't sealed properly, or you're not covering scraps thoroughly with bran.
Nothing's happening: Bran might be old or inactive. Try fresh bran or add more per layer.
Using Milk Kefir Whey as Inoculant
This is my favorite method because if you're already making milk kefir, you've got perfect inoculant just sitting there. The whey from straining kefir cheese or Greek-style kefir is packed with lactobacillus bacteria—exactly what you need.
Why it works:
- Lactobacillus bacteria are the stars of bokashi fermentation
- Your kefir whey is already acidic, which helps
- It's free if you're making kefir anyway
- Same bacteria, different application
To use: Simply substitute 500ml of kefir whey for the inoculant in the recipe above. If your whey is very thick, dilute it slightly with water. Otherwise, follow the same method.
You can also use whey from yogurt-making or cheesemaking—any acidic whey that's resulted from lacto-fermentation.
Using Sauerkraut juice (the brine) as an innoculant
Easy and also readily available in your kitchen - this is full of lactobacillus bacteria—it's lacto-fermented just like kefir whey. Same family of beneficial bacteria, slightly different strains, but they'll do the job perfectly well.
The considerations:
Salt content: Sauerkraut brine is typically 2-3% salt, which is higher than whey but not problematic. The bacteria in bokashi can handle that level of salt without issue. If you're using very salty brine (like from a long-fermented kraut), you might want to dilute it slightly with water.
Acidity: Sauerkraut juice is already acidic (low pH), which is exactly what you want for bokashi. That acidity helps the beneficial bacteria dominate.
Bacterial diversity: Sauerkraut brine might have a slightly different mix of lactobacillus species than milk kefir, but they all produce lactic acid and create the right conditions for bokashi fermentation.
To use it:
Just substitute 500ml of sauerkraut brine for the whey in the recipe. If your brine seems particularly salty or concentrated, you could do:
- 250ml sauerkraut juice
- 250ml water
- 3 tablespoons molasses
Mix with your wheat bran and proceed as normal.
Other fermentation liquids that work:
- Kimchi juice (although the spices might add interesting character and smell!, I'd rather use it for cooking or drinking.)
- Pickle brine from lacto-fermented pickles (same as the kimchi juice really - use it as a hydrolite)
- Water kefir
- Whey from any fermented dairy
Basically, any liquid from a successful lacto-fermentation will have the right bacteria. It's all the same principle—just different starting materials.
Scaling the Recipe
The ratio is approximately:
- 10 parts bran
- 1 part liquid mixture (water + inoculant + molasses)
So for a smaller batch:
- 2.5kg bran
- 250ml total liquid (water, whey, and molasses)
For a larger batch:
- 10kg bran
- 1L total liquid
Adjust based on how the moisture feels—you're aiming for that wrung-out sponge consistency.
Notes:
Bokashi composting is fermentation applied to kitchen waste—same principles, different outcome. Instead of sauerkraut, you're making pre-compost. Instead of probiotic food, you're creating probiotic soil amendment.
If you're already comfortable with fermentation, making your own bokashi bran is straightforward and saves serious money. Use the whey from your kefir or yogurt, mix it with grain and molasses, ferment for a few weeks, and you've got months of supply.
It's a beautiful closed loop: your milk kefir whey inoculates the bokashi bran, which ferments your kitchen scraps, which feeds your garden, which grows your food. That's the kind of resourcefulness that makes sense.
See also: Fermenting Rice Wash Water for the Garden | Making Milk Kefir | The Science of Fermentation